Dialogue in Times Square


By Seth Trochtenberg

Do you live?

I think I do.

I’d scream in joy.

I don’t remember that.

So you rest in memories, and find peace there?

I still see much, within the memories that is.

And find peace?

I find little.

Do you find me among it all?

Occasionally.

At times?

I know you, and so know nothing—a ghost in photographs.

I am fathomless and incapable of making out what I encounter.

I am haunted.

You have learned your limitations.

I’ve always been aware of such truths: you don’t aspire to such depth.

Great work!

You mock my efforts in praise, and somehow do it earnestly,

but to that end there looms just a question.

And that is?

Why did you endure and suffer; so that I may only mourn you?

I worry that was three questions, actually. You ask too much.

You are a mute. I speak enough for us both, so that words are still said.

Silence speaks for me.

I suppose so, but not well.

See, you extend yourself foolishly, and consider yourself profound in doing it.

I only consider myself, neither profound nor foolish

or any other demeanor you insist on me.

You do only consider yourself.

I do, if only because you say so. Does that make me the villain still,

even in my own story?

By silence, I am tied by jagged ropes to rails, and the train chugs on

the wrong track, mocking me as it passes by like unbridled time.

Hello?

Ah, I did miss these chats, like before we were strangers